| Plainsman | ||
| Alias | Overall | Time |
| Solicitor General | 1 | 203.22 |
| Lineas A. Puffbuster | 2 | 228.02 |
| Johnny Meadows | 3 | 230.00 |
| Durango Kid | 4 | 230.48 |
| Reverend Trinity | 5 | 231.49 |
| Lefty Eastman | 6 | 239.68 |
| Constable Nelson | 7 | 244.33 |
| Mason Stillwell | 8 | 270.32 |
| Dubious Don | 9 | 276.75 |
| Sheriff Pack Wolf | 10 | 276.82 |
| Tex | 11 | 277.24 |
| Bad Gene Poole | 12 | 285.20 |
| Just Plain Larry | 13 | 286.47 |
| Lefty Henderson | 14 | 294.20 |
| Sweettooth Kelley | 15 | 294.85 |
| Joe LaFives | 16 | 303.63 |
| Wild Bill Munch | 17 | 345.49 |
| Earl Brasse | 18 | 366.11 |
| Wooly Lum | 19 | 377.14 |
| Diamond Bob Younger | 20 | 480.64 |
| Oak Creek Lawman | 21 | 568.35 |
| Rowdy Otis | 22 | 2225.55 |
| Caddo Bob | 23 | 2303.37 |